The Informativeness of Consolidated and Parent-Only Earnings to Investors: Evidence from India

By Sudhakar V. Balachandran, Sudershan Kuntluru, Hariom Manchiraju, Sumeet Rajput
Contemporary Accounting Research | November 2025

DOI

 https://doi.org/10.1111/1911-3846.70013

Citation

Contemporary Accounting Research 

Copyright

Contemporary Accounting Research | November 2025

Share:
Abstract

We examine whether earnings from parent-only financial statements are incrementally informative to those from consolidated financial statements. We use a unique mandate in India that requires firms to provide both consolidated and parent-level financial statements, since currently neither US GAAP nor IFRS mandates this level of disaggregation. While disaggregation provides additional information, it also imposes costs, raising the empirical question of whether its benefits outweigh the costs. Our analyses reveal that disaggregated quarterly earnings components inform investors, with investors placing more weight on parent-level unexpected earnings than on subsidiaries' unexpected earnings. We do not find evidence of mispricing associated with disaggregation; rather, the higher weight on the parent's earnings reflects higher persistence, consistent with semi-strong market efficiency. Moreover, parent earnings provide incremental informativeness, especially in the context of poor earnings quality and high mergers and acquisitions intensity. Our results endure when we examine annual parent- and subsidiary-level earnings, where available, in 98 countries around the world. Our results contribute to the literature on disaggregation in accounting and earnings informativeness in equity markets, offering insights that may influence regulatory considerations on the usefulness of financial statement disaggregation.

Hariom Manchiraju is an Associate Professor of Accounting at the Indian School of Business (ISB). He holds a PhD and an MBA from the State University of New York – Buffalo, a Master of Financial Management (MFM) from Sri Satya Sai University, India, and Bachelor’s degree in Commerce from Osmania University, India.

His research focuses on the usefulness of accounting information in capital markets, the characteristics and value of financial forecasts issued by managers and analysts, and topics related to executive compensation and corporate governance.

His teaching interests lie in financial accounting, particularly financial statement analysis for MBA students and advanced financial accounting for senior undergraduates. He is a member of the American Accounting Association.

Prof Hariom Manchiraju
Hariom Manchiraju